Why Watch That

Top Menu

  • About
  • About
  • Advertise with Us
  • Checkout
    • Purchase Confirmation
    • Purchase History
    • Transaction Failed
  • Checkout
    • Purchase Confirmation
    • Purchase History
    • Transaction Failed
  • Co-Hosts
  • Co-Hosts 1
  • Contact
  • Content Search Int
  • Critic’s Thoughts
  • Enter for a chance to win OVERLORD on Blu-ray & 4K Ultra HD
  • Enter for a chance to win WHAT MEN WANT on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win a Pet Sematary on 4K
  • Enter for a chance to win a Pet Sematary on 4K
  • Enter for a chance to win A QUIET PLACE on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win a Remastered 25th Anniversary copy of FORREST GUMP on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win ACTION POINT on Blu-Ray/DVD
  • Enter for a chance to win BOOK CLUB on Blu-Ray/DVD
  • Enter for a chance to win Braveheart & Gladiator on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a chance to win Daddy’s Home 2 on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win FATHER’S DAY PRIZE PACK on Blu-ray and DVD
  • Enter for a chance to win Fences on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win Ghost in the Shell on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win Inside Amy Schumer: Season 4 on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win Juice on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a chance to win MISSION: IMPOSSIBLE 1-5 on 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win Office Christmas Party on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win Same Kind of Different as Me on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win Saturday Night Fever on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a chance to win season 2 of The Shannara Chronicles on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a chance to win SEASON ONE OF JACK RYAN on Blu-ray and DVD
  • Enter for a chance to win Silence on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win South Park 20th Season on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a chance to win South Park Season 1-5 on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win Suburbicon on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win The Godfather & The Godfather: Part II on Blu Ray
  • Enter for a chance to win THE JACK RYAN COLLECTION on 4K Ultra HD/Blu-ray
  • Enter for a chance to win TRANSFORMERS on Blu-ray
  • Enter for a Chance to Win Workaholics Complete Series on DVD
  • Events
  • First Annual Why Watch That Awards Voting
  • Giveaways
  • Guest Hosts
  • Home
  • homefortheholidays
  • Homepage
  • Homepage New
  • Interviews
  • Jobs
  • Love What You Watch Kit
  • Podcasts
  • Press
  • Privacy Policy
  • Radio
  • Referee Recommends
  • Resources
  • Reviews
  • Reviews in a Snap
  • Sample Page
  • Shop WWT
  • Support
  • Terms and Conditions
  • The Team
  • The Why Watch That TV Tracker
  • TV Reviews
  • Win a FATHER’S DAY GIFT giveaway
  • Written Reviews

Main Menu

  • Latest
  • Reviews
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Written
    • Festivals

logo

Why Watch That

  • Latest
  • Reviews
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Written
    • Festivals
  • Why Watch That Conclusion and Thank You

  • Is The Gentlemen an Amazing Example of Harnessed Excess?

  • Will Constellation Shock You Into a New Reality?

  • Will The New Look Rise out of the Ashes of War?

  • Is The Taste of Things a Recipe for Quiet Magic?

  • Can Mads Mikkelsen Fight His Way to The Promised Land?

  • Is All Creatures Great and Small the Perfect Uplifting Escape?

  • Is The Brothers Sun a Thrilling Way to Start the Year?

Reviews
Home›Reviews›Sneak Peek: Coming Through the Rye

Sneak Peek: Coming Through the Rye

By WWTR
October 13, 2016
1815
0
Share:

coming-through-the-rye-posterIn theaters October 14, 2016.

Inspired by events in the life of the filmmaker. It is 1969. 16 yr. old Jamie Schwartz (Alex Wolff), desperate to be a worldly adolescent, has landed at an all-boys boarding school for all the wrong reasons. Ostracized by nearly everyone, he clings to the unshakable belief that he will someday play Holden Caulfield — the main character from the book The Catcher in the Rye — on Broadway and in the movies. Jamie adapts the novel into a play to put on at school, but after a series of increasingly hostile incidents he runs away to search for the book’s reclusive author, JD Salinger (Chris Cooper). On the way Deedee Gorlin (Stefania Owen), a quirky townie, picks him up. Their odyssey to find Salinger and the roller-coaster of events that follow is a journey into the meanings of friendship, sex, love and loss.

Starring: Academy Award-Winner Chris Cooper as J.D. Salinger, Alex Wolff (TV’s “The Naked Brother Band,” The Sitter, Peter Berg’s upcoming Patriot’s Day), and Stefania Owen (upcoming Hulu series “Chance” with Hugh Laurie, TV’s “The Carrie Diaries,” ALL WE HAD)

Written & Directed by: Jim Sadwith

Runtime: 95 minutes
Rated PG-13


This transcript has been lightly edited:

The Referee: Hey, listeners. The Critic and I got a chance to see a Sneak Peek of a movie coming out tomorrow. That’s right: October 14. It is going to get you excited about reading “The Catcher in the Rye”! (laughter)

The Critic: (laughing) Weren’t we already excited?

Ref: (laughs) Yes, we were. It’s called “Coming Through the Rye.” And, as you guessed, it has to do with “The Catcher in the Rye.” We’ll tell you a little bit how. But, it’s directed and written by James Steven Sadwith, who also had a very personal experience with some of the events of the movie. It stars the wonderful Alex Wolff, who you can see in some upcoming things. And, then, of course: Chris Cooper, playing J.D. Salinger! (laughter) I mean, come on! With eyebrows and all. (laughter) Stefania LaVie Owen, as well as some others: We’ll get to them. Let’s tell the listeners a little bit [about] what this is about.

Critic: (laughing) It’s about eyebrows. Anyway —

Ref: It is: talking eyebrows.

Critic: So, Alex Wolff plays Jamie Schwartz. He’s a 16-year-old, who is in prep school. And, this is 1969. He’s in prep school. You know he’s being bullied. He’s a theater geek. And, he’s decided to write a play version of “The Catcher in the Rye,” because, of course, Holden Caulfield is his hero. Makes sense: He wears the red hat —

Ref: Yup, everything.

YouTube video

Critic: He wants to get J.D. Salinger, the author of “The Catcher in the Rye” — his permission to do this. And, J.D. Salinger is a recluse. He doesn’t want anybody touching his book. He wants the book to be the book, and that’s it. No adaptations; no one is allowed: not Scorsese, not you (laughter), nobody. OK? So, we see Jamie try to track J.D. Salinger down: going to his agents, going to the town, eventually. And, who goes along with him? None other than Deedee, a character played by Stefania LaVie Owen. She is at a girl’s prep school —

Ref: Like the sister school, almost.

Critic: Exactly. She notices him; he doesn’t notice her. He has goo-goo eyes for a young blonde, of course, who couldn’t care less about him. But, they’re all in the drama group. So, they team up, Deedee and Jamie. And, on this journey, they discover each other, as well, in a way that is reminiscent of Holden Caulfield, of course. So, does he find J.D. Salinger? What is J.D. Salinger’s reaction to it? Does the play go? Because, this is his project for school. He needs to get it done. And, the bullying at the school: Why did it happen? And, after it happens, is it going to stop?

Ref: Yeah, that’s good. Now, the subplot of all of that is there’s some really heavy things going on at home —

Critic: Yes.

Ref: — for young Jamie, that really is a catalyst as to why he does go on this search and journey. So, you’ll have to pay attention to that, as well.

coming-through-the-rye-1

Critic: Yeah, it’s all linked with the bullying and the home life and the search and Holden Caulfield. It’s a lot going on in this little movie. I mean, it’s only an hour, 37 minutes. (laughs) OK?

Ref: Well, you know what? I have to say: I’m just gonna go right into the performances. It’s Chris Cooper, you guys. He only really has two scenes in the movie, and you’ll know exactly what they are — what he’s doing.

Critic: Yeah.

Ref: And, he is the rye guy! (laughs)

Critic: Yes.

Ref: The movie really builds up to him, and Chris Cooper, obviously, doesn’t slight. You’ll remember him and remember his angst and his frustration (laughter) and his eyebrows —

Critic: His eyebrows and the posture. (laughs)

Ref: (still laughing) You’ll remember his eyebrows. Quite frankly, I wish we could’ve had more.

Critic: Yeah.

coming-through-the-rye-4

Ref: I wish the movie was a little bit more about him, because Chris Cooper’s so good. But, I do have to say: Young Alex Wolff is quite the actor. He’s one to watch. He holds the scenes quite well, doing a lot of improv that you can see he’s a very playful actor. You can see him thinking. He works well with others. He was not overtaken by Chris Cooper in the scenes.

Critic: No.

Ref: I think he’s really one to watch. Other than that, I just have to really talk about the challenges —

Critic: Yeah.

Ref: — that were with that: and that was with the story. Because, there were so many elements, as a viewer, I didn’t know what quite to watch.

Critic: Yeah.

Ref: I liked what I saw, aesthetically. The director did a wonderful job, aesthetically: the beautiful nature scenes that take place. But, I really didn’t know exactly what I was supposed to focus on, and that was a bit of a challenge for me. But, was I bored out of my mind? Absolutely not! It’s a good movie.

coming-through-the-rye-2

Critic: Yeah, it has its moments. In the middle, for me, it was a little wonky. [But] I understand why we went through what we went through. I think, like you said about Alex: For me, really, the ending for him was a challenging thing to pull off, and he did it. I think that that actually worked. And, like you said with Chris Cooper: The thing about Alex is [that] he’s a great listener as an actor. And, like you were saying, with improv, that’s what it comes from if you’re going to be good at that. You really have to be paying attention and listening. So, he did that well. I think, cast-wise, it was fine. I was cool with the cast. It’s just, some of the writing wasn’t quite as clear and concise as it could’ve been. So, if we’re thinking: Why watch that? We said it: It’s for Alex; it’s for Chris Cooper; also, if you’re just interested in “The Catcher in the Rye,” to see how that plays out — OK. It’s not gonna blow you away. It’ll be something to catch on TV, probably.

Ref: Yeah, definitely. So, this comes out tomorrow, folks. You can check it out at a theater near you. And, you let us know if you like “Coming Through the Rye.”

Previous Article

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (Trailer ...

Next Article

Sneak Peek: Certain Women

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Related articles More from author

  • Reviews

    Sneak Peek: Hidden Figures

    December 23, 2016
    By WWTR
  • EpisodeReviews

    Movie & TV Talk: Marry Me, The Worst Person in the World, The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, Severance, and A Taste ...

    February 17, 2022
    By The Critic & The Ref
  • Reviews

    Is Raising Kanan the Ultimate Winner in the Power Universe?

    December 15, 2023
    By WWTR
  • Mending the Line
    Reviews

    Mending the Line

    June 10, 2023
    By WWTR
  • Reviews

    Review: Brother

    August 4, 2023
    By WWTR
  • Review: Somewhere in Queens
    Reviews

    Review: Somewhere in Queens

    April 25, 2023
    By WWTR

  • Episode

    TV Talk: Bless This Mess, Ramy, Star Trek:Discovery, The Magicians and More TV!

  • Reviews

    Sneak Peek: Spider-Man: Far From Home

  • Episode

    TV Talk: Stumptown, Almost Family, Raising Dion, Goliath, Get Shorty, and Poldark

  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Why Watch That Conclusion and Thank You

    By wwcadmin
    July 8, 2024
  • Is The Gentlemen an Amazing Example of Harnessed Excess?

    By WWTR
    March 7, 2024
  • Will Constellation Shock You Into a New Reality?

    By WWTR
    February 20, 2024
  • Sneak Peek: The Birth of a Nation (2016)

    By WWTR
    October 2, 2016
  • Jack Reacher: Never Go Back

    By WWTR
    June 22, 2016
  • Sneak Peek: The Intervention

    By WWTR
    August 25, 2016

Sponsor

  • About
  • Advertise with Us
  • Jobs
  • Support
  • The Team
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact
Why Watch That 2023